AI-generated, human-reviewed.

Microsoft's September 2025 Patch Tuesday delivered one of the year's most substantial Windows 11 updates, but the Windows Weekly panel wasn't entirely celebratory. While the update brings meaningful improvements to search, notifications, and customization, it also amplifies ongoing concerns about interface bloat and contradicts Windows 11's original simplification promises.

The Good: Search and Interface Modernization

The update introduces several genuinely useful improvements. Search from the taskbar now displays images in a modern grid view, bringing Windows closer to contemporary web search experiences. The Notification center finally restores the larger clock option that Windows 10 users missed, addressing a long-standing complaint.

System dialogs now appear modally with dimmed backgrounds, creating better visual focus. Lock screen widgets gain much-needed customization options, allowing users to add, remove, and rearrange widgets with new compact sizing options.

These changes represent the kind of quality-of-life improvements that actually enhance daily Windows usage without adding complexity.

The Concerning: Context Menu Explosion

However, Paul Thurrott raised serious concerns about the growing complexity of File Explorer's right-click menus. The Windows Weekly discussion highlighted how these menus continue expanding despite Windows 11's original goal of interface simplification.

The addition of AI-powered "app actions" threatens to make context menus even more unwieldy. Thurrott noted that while only a small percentage of Windows users actually right-click in File Explorer, those who do will face increasingly crowded interfaces. He described this growth pattern as problematic, comparing it to something that "metastasizes" and keeps getting worse regardless of user needs.

Microsoft does provide management controls through Settings > Privacy & security > Text and Image Generation, but most users won't discover or configure these options.

Windows Hello: Pretty But Problematic

The Windows Hello redesign exemplifies the update's mixed results. While the new interface looks more modern and provides better authentication option switching, the Windows Weekly team noted a significant downside: it's noticeably slower and more tedious than the previous version.

This trade-off between visual appeal and functional efficiency reflects broader concerns about Microsoft prioritizing aesthetics over productivity—a recurring theme in Windows 11's evolution.

Copilot+ PC Features: Limited Audience

For the small percentage of users with Copilot+ PCs, this update enhances AI-powered features like Recall and Click to Do. Recall gains a new homepage with activity shortcuts and improved filtering, while Click to Do adds interactive tutorials.

However, these exclusive features primarily serve Microsoft's marketing narrative rather than addressing widespread user needs, as acknowledged during the Windows Weekly discussion.

The Bigger Picture: Simplification Abandoned?

The panel's analysis revealed a fundamental tension in Windows 11's development. Microsoft originally promoted simplification as a core principle, yet four and a half years later, interfaces are becoming more complex than ever.

Thurrott emphasized how this contradicts user expectations and creates frustration for people trying to accomplish everyday tasks efficiently. The constant addition of new features and AI integrations suggests Microsoft has moved away from its simplification goals in favor of feature proliferation.

What This Means for Users

This update may represent the final major monthly feature drop before Windows 11 version 25H2 arrives, though the Windows Weekly team expressed some uncertainty about Microsoft's exact timeline.

For most users, expect:

• Familiar workflows to look different after the update
• Improved customization options for widgets and notifications
• Longer context menus that may slow down power users
• Mixed results from interface changes—some helpful, others frustrating

Key Points

• Substantial visual and functional improvements to search and notifications
• Context menus growing longer despite original simplification promises
• Windows Hello redesigned but performance suffers significantly
• AI features expanding but primarily benefit small hardware subset
• Microsoft appears to have abandoned interface simplification philosophy
• May be final major update before Windows 11 25H2 transition

The Bottom Line

While September's Patch Tuesday brings genuine improvements to Windows 11's core functionality, it also highlights Microsoft's struggle to balance innovation with usability. The Windows Weekly analysis suggests that Microsoft's pursuit of new features—particularly AI integration—is undermining the clean, simplified experience originally promised with Windows 11. Users should prepare for continued interface evolution that may prioritize capabilities over simplicity.

Subscribe to Windows Weekly for unfiltered analysis of Microsoft's latest developments: https://twit.tv/shows/windows-weekly/episodes/949