Penny thought her dinner date with Abraham was a hit — great vibes, shared laughs, and even dessert. She encouraged him to send back his disappointing dish, thinking that was the only hiccup of the night. But midway through dinner, Penny dropped a piece of personal news that left Abraham baffled and unsure about her intentions. And that’s the real reason he’s been silent ever since.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.