
ยทS2
Is Flavor Really All In Your Brain?
Episode Transcript
Guess what will what's that mango?
So I was watching this old BBC clip online of an electronic lollipop.
What is that?
So it's not actually a candy.
The lollipop is still being developed in labs.
But it's this gentle clamp that slides metal plates over the top and bottomy tongue.
I don't think it helps to call this clamp gentle.
That still doesn't sound that appealing.
Well, here's what's cool about it.
So it sends currents through your tongue and adjust the temperature on those plates, and the electronic lollipop can actually trick your tongue into thinking it's tasting a wide variety of flavors, like a lemony sour taste is the easiest to pull off, and scientists can do reasonable approximations of other flavors.
But the application of all this is really cool.
Like imagine you're watching Iron Chef and Bobby Flay is on there and he's just made the most amazing eggplant spaghetti taco in the world, and you can't figure out for the life of you what an eggplant plus spaghetti and a taco shell should taste like, And so you just take a lick of your lollipop and suddenly you get a sense of that flavor.
Speaker 2Wow.
Speaker 3I mean, that's kind of weird, but it is pretty cool.
Reminds me a little bit of smell vision, except for your taste bud exactly.
And you can see how this might be used in online grocery shopping in the future or checking out new recipes.
It's totally fascinating.
But what I found most interesting in all of this are the limitations.
Because these currents are only playing with your tongue, they can only create a set of basic flavors.
But when the scientists added technology that incorporates your nose, suddenly the range of flavors expanded dramatically, and that got me thinking what other tricks can we play on our tongue and how much a flavor is really just something constructed in our brain.
Speaker 2So that's what this episode is all about.
Speaker 3Hey, their podcast listeners, Welcome to Part Time Genius.
I'm Will Pearson and as always I'm joined by my good friend mangesh Hot Ticketer, and today I'm here to address a big problem in the English language.
Speaker 1I'm pretty sure we were talking about starting sentences with because because my second grade English teacher had the same argument with me.
Speaker 3Wait, this was second grade.
You got in trouble in second grade for starting sentences.
Speaker 1Was because yeah, actually it was more of a thing that she said we shouldn't do.
And then I started every sentence in a story with a word because it was not a good strategy for going to recess that.
Speaker 3All right, Well, at some point we'll do a whole episode on grammar, so you can save your SOB stories for then.
But today I'm talking about how English speakers use the words taste and flavor interchangeably, as though they mean the same thing.
Speaker 1Wait, they don't mean the same thing.
Speaker 3I know, it's pretty crazy.
So I've been reading this new book called Flavor.
It's by Bob Holmes, and it's really good.
As Holmes explains, taste is just one component of flavor, and he writes, the best way to think about flavor is that it's the sum of all the sensations we get when we have food in the mouth.
So think about the weight of the bowl, the color of the plate, the crunch of the potato chip.
Even the choice of background music can have a direct effect on how we perceive flavor.
Speaker 1It's funny because when I think of flavor, it seems like such a specific thing, like popcorn flavor, jelly beans, that's a flavor.
Speaker 3I think there might be some people who disagree with you on this, but.
Speaker 1I know what you're saying is true.
Like taste and smell and touch and sound, they all play a role in how much we appreciate food.
I guess I've just been using the wrong vocabulary.
Speaker 3All right.
Well, I'm not here to flavor Shandy, but we do have Bob Holmes on the show today, which is super exciting, and we'll be talking to him about flavor and some of the fascinating studies and facts he covered in his book.
Speaking of which, do you have a terrible quiz lined up for us today?
Oh?
Speaker 1Of course I do.
Sticking with the flavors theme, we're playing real vintage recipe or gourmet cat food flavor.
It's a little harder than you think.
Speaker 3Awesome, all right, all right, Well, let's kick this off by talking about taste.
Even if it's not the same thing as flavor, it's obviously an important thing, definitely so.
Speaker 1In the English speaking world, psychologists have traditionally acknowledged four different tastes.
They're sweet, sour, salty, and bitter, and humans have different receptors for each of these.
And then more recently, we've added a fifth taste, umami, which kind of just sounds made up, so we need to talk about that.
Speaker 3Yeah, it did feel like a few years ago people started talking about umami and it was like breaking news, like did you hear about this umami flavor?
And actually, to be honest, I got confused.
I was mixing it up with the word unagi, which is the Japanese word for fresh water eel, so I was trying to understand why eel got to be a flavor of its own.
I mean, don't get me wrong, I love eel, but it was still a little confusing.
Speaker 1Yeah, it was confusing to me because I thought we were getting a brand new flavor, like you know that apartment you have, did you know it's been hiding a secret room all this time?
Or like you're familiar with the rainbow, guess what we're adding a new color exactly, And instead it was like, you know, parmesan cheese or soy sauce, those are umami.
You just didn't have a word for it, right, But umami is definitely distinct.
Yeah, it's a Japanese word meaning delicious flavor and linguists usually translated as savory or maybe meaty, and his Homes explains there are a few reasons why it takes a while to rap your head around what umami is.
First, is that, unlike other tastes, you don't really experience umami as this isolated thing.
Think about it.
You can bite into a strawberry and immediately experience that as sweet, or lick a French fry and no, that's kind of a salty taste.
Speaker 3I think we've talked about this.
You've got to stop licking your French fries.
That's a little weird.
Speaker 1They're just so good though.
But anyway, you can experience those tastes in a pretty pure and direct form.
With umami, it's more in combination with other things.
Taste researcher Paul Breslin also points out that the receptors for umami have a pretty low maximum intensity compared to other tastes, which prevents us from being able to note something as being very umami, unlike how we might say something's very sweet or very salty.
Speaker 3Yeah, and there's a much stronger cultural element than I realized.
I mean, I know the stereotypes of different cultures being able to handle different levels of spice or things like that, but I really didn't think about how that could be applied to something like umami.
But it turns out many people in Asian countries have no problem identifying things as umami, but they have the same ease that American children have identifying things as sweet.
It's really interesting how taste has developed differently in different places around the world.
Speaker 1Well, let's back up for a minute and talk about how these tastes would have developed from an evolutionary perspective.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's one thing for us to identify or talk about these tastes when we cook at home or eat at restaurants now, but for our ancestors, these tastes were key to survival.
So think about how a sweet taste would have let someone know that they were getting sugars, which are an important way to get calories for energy, or tasting salt would be an indication of electrolytes, and a mommy would have indicated the presence of proteins.
Now, on the negative side, our ancestors learned from bitter taste that something might be toxic, or from sourness that a fruit might have gone bad or just not be good to eat.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's not hard to see how we'd be hardwired to like sweet, salty, and a mommy.
And it's equally fascinating to see how other animals have evolved differently because of their different nutritional needs.
Like there was a cat study.
It's oh great, it's back.
Well, a study was done that showed cats, because their carnivores are unable to really identify sweetness and it has no appeal for them.
And pandas, who are some serious bamboo eaters, don't really need to identify umami, so they've lost the ability to taste it well.
Speaker 3And even more extreme than that, vampire bat's love of blood has caused them to lose the ability to taste umami sweet and bitter.
I'm actually curious why we don't do a bad study like we do cat studies.
Have I mentioned I don't like cats.
I think you've mentioned that a few times, all right, I just wanted to make sure.
So back to how we've evolved, there's another thing about taste that I think is just crazy interesting.
So just as we're discussing how flavor is much more than just taste.
Taste also happens to be more complex than we thought.
Did you know that there are taste receptors in multiple places around our body, not just our mouth?
Speaker 1Sure, it's crazy, isn't it.
Speaker 3Wait, so that means you do know about this.
I'm gonna quiz you.
So, do we have taste receptors in our lungs?
Speaker 2Yes?
Speaker 3What about our guts?
Speaker 1Yes?
Speaker 3What about it our brain?
Yes?
What about our forte?
Speaker 1Definitely no, we don't.
Speaker 3We do not have taste receptors in our forehead.
You slum dog millionaireed me you should know about it.
There's no cheating on our quizzes.
So this isn't exactly well understood yet, but it's really fascinating.
The ones in the gut, for example, detective Mommy and sweet and let our brains know that some yummy and nutritious food has arrived, and if they taste something bitter, they let us know there may be a problem and trigger a response of some kind.
So you can get the sense for why they're helpful.
But why do you think we need taste receptors in our respiratory system?
Speaker 1So it's one way of letting our bodies know if bacteria has arrived because bacteria have a communication chemical with a bitter taste, and when the receptor is in our respiratory system, notice this, they help our bodies mount response.
There's even some thinking among scientists that these bitter receptors may have existed in other areas of our body, first as a way of detecting infection and then moving to our mouths.
Speaker 3Yes, Holmes explains.
If this is the case, we have disease to thank for the flavor of coffee, beer, and broccoli.
Speaker 1It's weird, right, all right.
So I know in a few minutes we're going to play a quiz, but before we do that, I think we should find out whether we're super tasters.
Speaker 3Super tasters Well.
Speaker 1It's not as exciting as it sounds, because while it does mean someone has a more intense sense of taste, supertasters tend to be much more bland eaters because most tastes tend to be that much more extreme for them.
Speaker 3Well, given the fact that the last time we ate at the Chinese place downstairs, it looked to me like you just ordered a plate of hot peppers, So I'm guessing you're not a super taster.
Speaker 1Yeah, we had a joke in our family that our dad served as so much spicy food that we burned off our taste buds.
Speaker 3I believe that.
Speaker 1Let me show you how we test for this using this filter paper.
Each strip has a small amount of a bitter compound on them.
It's called prople thigh ORUSIL or PROP.
So we're going to put these on our tongues and find out which of these three categories of tasters we fall in.
Non tasters will taste nothing, tasters will notice the bitter taste but it's not a huge deal, and super taste will have this super strong response to it.
Speaker 3All right, I like this.
We should also get some other members of the PTG team in here.
Speaker 1What do you say?
Speaker 4Yeah?
Speaker 1Definitely?
Speaker 3All right, so let's give this a shot.
So we've got two of our team members joining us.
We've got Noel Brown, you may know from stuff they don't want you to know, also a supervising producer on the show, and Jerry Roland, our executive producer.
Here, guys, you guys ready to give this a shot?
Am I ever?
Speaker 2Okay?
Speaker 3All right, So we've all got these strips and on the count of three, we're going to put them on our tongues.
We're going to see what happens now.
As a reminder, if you taste nothing, which may be the case, you're a non taster.
If you taste a little bit of bitter, just some bitter, then you're a taster.
And if it tastes extremely better, then you are a super taster.
So ready, all right on the count of three, one, two, three.
I don't know it sides.
You may have to flip it out.
Oh wait, you get something I got?
I got a hint of bitter.
Uh huh.
Mine is totally bitter.
It's like great fruit bitter.
Oh nice, I have a real paper taste, but I mean something completely different.
We can't talk about it.
Might be fooling myself about this.
Oh Jerry, she's running away.
Speaker 1She's always had great.
Speaker 3Is blown?
I hate grapefruit, super taster.
Okay, spicy food, Jerry, I love spicy food.
But you just like the torture.
I guess I'm not sure what's happening.
Wow, oh man, that's so disappointing.
You've given us a lot to think about it.
Speaker 1Yeah, I feel like I'm so cheated.
Like not only can I not see those like three D magic pictures, but also I can't taste these people.
Speaker 3Yeah, this is the worse.
Okay, that's a bummer.
I was getting.
I think I was getting a slight taste of bitter.
Okay, here we go.
Well, while we're having so much fun, when you say we play a little quiz, sounds good.
Speaker 4All right.
Speaker 3So who do we have on the line today, Mango.
Speaker 1We've got Sarah Fiddler, who's got one of the list jobs in the world.
She's a flavor guru at one of my favorite ice cream companies, Ben and Jerry's.
Speaker 3We are so excited to have you on.
Welcome to part time Genia.
Speaker 1Sarah, thank you for having me.
Speaker 3So I'm really curious how you got this job.
I mean, what sort of training and schooling do you have to have to become a Ben and Jerry's flavor guru.
Speaker 5Well, personally, I have a degree in food science from the University of Vermont and a degree in baking and pastry from the Culinary Institute of America.
There are a group of us flavor gurus here, and everybody's got kind of a mixed background, from chefs to food scientists, all comes from different backgrounds.
Speaker 3It's very cool, that's awesome.
And how are flavors decided upon?
Like, how do you guys decide you have so many fun and creative and awesome flavors, how do you guys come up with these?
Speaker 5Well, we start out by being very creative and kind of playing around in our test kitchens, and then we meet with our marketing team, our brand management team, sometimes our social mission team and figure out which of our crazy flavors makes the most sense to launch for the next season.
Speaker 1And so, how many flavors are you typically playing with?
Speaker 5It could be arranged anywhere from maybe three to ten at a time.
Speaker 1That's pretty crazy.
I heard that the Ben and Jerry's staff takes a field trip every year to research new flavors.
Is that true?
Speaker 5Yeah.
We go on what we call trend tracks.
Pick a city or area that seems to be filled with really up and coming food places, sometimes cocktail places, farms, and go as a group and eat as much as we possibly can, and then come back and make ice cream inspired by what we ate.
Speaker 1Cool, But where are some of the fun places you've trekked to?
Speaker 5Well, I'm relatively new to the company, so I have yet to go on a track, but I've heard that they've gone to San Francisco, Portland's I believe there was a trip to Japan before I started.
Speaker 1Very cool.
Speaker 3Wow, I'm so jealous of this job.
That sounds pretty great.
Now we also know about the flavor graveyard at Ben and Jerry.
So are there are there ceremonies when flavors are buried there?
And how does this work?
How do you pay your respects?
Speaker 5I think for some of the flavors that were a little bit more loved, they do ceremonies, and sometimes it's more of a quiet affair.
Speaker 3We won't get into that then.
So that's pretty great.
All right, So manga, what game are we playing today with Sarah?
Speaker 1It's called do Me a Flavor?
Mostly because I just wanted to hear you say do me a flavor all things.
Speaker 3I really appreciate that.
That's a pretty terrible title of how do we play?
Speaker 1Basically, we're giving Sarah three popular flavors from an iconic food or drink brand, and she just has to tell us what we're talking about.
Speaker 3Okay, that sounds fun.
All right, Sarah, are you ready to play?
Speaker 5I'm ready?
Speaker 3Okay.
Question number one?
This chip comes in cool Ranch, Nacho cheese, and heat Wave flavors, So do me a flavor and tell me what product we're talking about.
Real yepah, you got it for one, question number two.
The most popular flavors of this candy include very cherry and buttered popcorn, though the blueberry flavor was particularly popular in the nineteen eighties when it was created for Ronald Reagan.
Do me a flavor, Manger, are you gonna make me say?
Speaker 1Do me a flavor?
Speaker 3Do me a flavor and tell me what brand we're.
Speaker 1Talking about jelly Belly.
Speaker 3You got it two for two for two question number three.
This sports drink originally came in lemon, lime, and orange flavors.
It has since expanded to include rainberry, glacier freeze, and cool blue.
Do me a flavor and tell me what beverage I'm talking about?
Betray Yes, all right, she's three for three.
Let's see if she can get the last two Question number four.
While this O shaped breakfast cereal does come in flavors like fruity and frosted, the most popular varieties are still original and honeynut.
Do me a flavor and tell me what breakfast cereal I'm talking about?
Curios.
Okay, we've saved the hardest for last.
Good luck on this one.
Okay, question number five.
This iconic ice cream brand has the best punny flavors, including Fish Food, American Dream, and the Tonight Dough.
Do me a flavor and tell me what really wonderful ice cream company we're talking about, Ben and Jerry.
All Right, that would have been kind of embarrassing if she'd missed out.
Speaker 1Well, Sarah when an astounding five for five, which wins her the grand prize, A hundred note from us to her mom or boss, singing her praises.
Speaker 3Wow.
Speaker 1So congratulations Sarah, and thank you so much for flaving.
Speaker 3That's awesome.
Congratulations Sarah, Thank you both.
Please tell all the people at Ben and Jerry's we say thank you for making wonderful ice or even keep up the great work.
I will.
Speaker 1Guess what will?
Speaker 3What's that mango?
Speaker 1I'm coming to terms with the fact that I'm not a super taste all right.
Speaker 3Well, lucky for you, we've been talking about the fact that flavor is so much more than just.
Speaker 1Taste, and then we just talked about taste.
But I think it's time we backed that statement off and talk about another key component of flavor, and that's smell, all.
Speaker 3Right, talk to me about smell.
Speaker 1Well, if you think taste is a complicated thing, it's nothing compared to the complexity of smell.
Think about the millions upon millions of smells in the world and how our noses have to make sense of them and help us identify what things are.
In fact, as Holmes points out, the old faction researcher Joel Mainland estimates that they're about twenty seven billion smelly molecules in the world.
Speaker 3Wow.
Speaker 1And while that doesn't mean they're about twenty seven billion smells because some might be identical, that still this incredible number.
Speaker 3Well, the other thing Holmes explains that I find so interesting, and this goes back to your electric lollipop example, but that's how different taste than smell are.
So our sense of taste is pretty easy to break down.
We can enjoy a dish of sweet and sour pork and understand that it's sweet and sour, or have some ketch up and know that it's sweet, sour, salty and umami.
And maybe we're not thinking about those things actively, but those are all there and we can identify them.
But smell is different because you really can't break it down.
Instead, our brains take all the information from the smelly molecules and create a single perception of smell.
As Holmes writes, if you combine ethyl isobutorate, which is a fruity odor, ethyl maltol, it's just caramel like an allyl alpha ionine, which is violet like in the proper proportions.
For example, what you smell is not caramel coated fruit on a bed of violets, but pineapple.
Speaker 1And how much more complicated by the fact that in English we really don't have the language to describe smells in any significant way other than seeing what they smell like.
So we might say something smells fishy or like grass or whatever.
But this isn't the case everywhere, and especially in places that depend much more on those smells for survival, such as the remaining hunter gatherer tribes.
Take the Jihai tribe of Thailand.
A research team set up a smell test between a group of Jehai men and a group of men from Texas, and when the Jahai men were presented with certain smells, they had just an easy time communicating what they smelled with very descriptive words, as they did in describing colors, and the Texans, on the other hand, were of course able to describe colors, but they struggled when asked to describe smells.
Speaker 3When there's one more reason why smell is just so difficult for us to understand and talk about.
Speaker 1What's not?
Speaker 3All right?
So humans have around four hundred odor receptors, but the part that makes things complicated is that only about half of those receptors work in pretty much everyone.
But then of the other half, there's this wide range of which ones work in some piece and not in others.
So that leads to an incredibly wide range of smells that humans are capable of processing.
In fact, for the most part, no two people have the same sense of smell, which is pretty crazy.
Speaker 1Yeah, but needless to say, our sense of smell makes a huge contribution to the flavors we process.
Speaker 3And there's another biggie to add to taste and smell, and that's the sense of touch.
Think about the burn of a chili pepper, or the chili feeling in your mouth when you're chewing on a minty piece of gum, or fizz in a carbonated drink.
Oh man, that first sip of a coke, how good is this first sip of a coke?
Speaker 1So good?
I think I'll have one right now.
Speaker 3All right to Atlanta.
So it's interesting how little is really understood about this component of flavor, at least how few studies have been done on it.
But we do know that spicy hot, for example, is not a taste.
It's something you feel.
And then we have specific receptors that cause the heat sensation when we eat spicy things.
Speaker 1Speaking of spicy hot, do you know how the Scoville units, which measure the heat of chili peppers got its start?
Speaker 3How's that?
Speaker 4Well?
Speaker 1Apparently it goes back to this pharmacist and researcher, Wilbur Scoville.
Scoville came up with the scale back in nineteen twelve, and it was a pretty smart way of doing it.
You figured out that you could create a scale based on the amount of dilution required before the burn of a chili could no longer be felt, so super hot pepper would take much more dilution.
Speaker 3Oh, that is pretty smart.
Speaker 1Yeah, And now it's easier for scientists to just measure the amount of capsaicin, which is the main ingredient that makes a chili hot, and then just convert those into Scoville units.
Speaker 3It's pretty wild how hot some peppers can be.
Take jalapenos, for example, which we think of is pretty hot.
They come in about five thousand Scovill units.
Cayennes are at about forty thousand.
The habban nio comes in at over one hundred thousand, maybe even up to three hundred thousand.
But even the hobbin niro doesn't hold a candle to the Carolina Reaper.
Speaker 1And how many Scoville units does that one have?
Speaker 3Two point two million.
It's unbelievable, it's crazy.
That's basically like police eat pepper spray.
And there's a new contender out there.
It's called Dragon's Breath, which is a tiny pepper that can possibly kill.
Speaker 1You, but it sounds so cute.
So we have Noel Brown here to test this out.
Why would you even make a pepper that hot.
Speaker 3Well, it's so unbelievably hot that can actually numb your skin to touch, and that makes it useful as an anesthetic in areas without medical supplies.
But let's leave the hottest of the hot peppers aside for a minute.
It's interesting that we humans enjoy inflicting this burning pain on ourselves, and we don't know exactly why this is.
I mean, I know, we know about the endorphin release that happens when we eat spicy foods, but that still doesn't answer the question of why that happened.
Speaker 1You know, first we feast, does that chili head enthusiast show.
And I was reading an interview that said it's much easier to get people to drop their inhibitions when they eat a chili pepper because they're like sweating and it's like they've just exercised.
So instead of those awkward questions you go through in the beginning of an interview, people just skip past that by eating chilis Wow.
Anyway.
We know humans like heat, but researchers have yet identify another mammal that seeks the heat of chili peppers.
I mean, birds eat plenty of them, but they don't actually have the receptors that would feel the heat of cupsason, so there's no sensation at all for them even in eating a super hot pepper.
I wonder if birds enjoy the first sip of a coke, oh man.
Speaker 3To it while we savor our beverages.
Why don't we take a break for a quiz.
Our guest today has been a science writer and correspondent for New Scientist magazine for over twenty years, and as the author of Flavor, the brilliant book we've been talking about in this episode, and for those who listen to our episode on How Clean We Should Be, you know, I'm not surprised that a New Scientist writer would produce such a great book.
Bob Holmes, Welcome to Part Time Genius.
Speaker 4Hi, thanks for having me.
Speaker 3Bob.
In Flavor, you mentioned that we can pretty much do away with the idea that we have previously had about taste maps, where different parts of our tongues helped us experience different taste.
So our taste maps really not a thing we should think about anymore.
Speaker 4They really aren't, and it's pretty easy to demonstrate that.
All you have to do is take a cute tip and dip it in salt water and rush it around your tongue.
You know, the taste map says that you say it's salty.
I think it's right at the tip of your tongue, and you'll find that you can taste the salt anywhere.
Speaker 3Huh.
So how did this come about?
Speaker 4I'm not sure.
It turns out there are slight differences in different parts of the tongue, and you've got a few more bitter taste bud's right at the back and a few more sweet at the front, and things like that, but it's not enough to make much of a difference at all.
Speaker 1You also write the possibility of a sixth taste or even more than that, and could you talk a little bit about that?
Speaker 4Sure, Yeah, I mean it's almost certainly at least it tastes and maybe quite a few more.
You know, we all know about sweet, salty, sour, bitter, and most of us know about umami, which is that fifth taste that's sort of safe retaste, but almost certain.
I think the evidence is really good now that there is in fact the taste for fat, or more specifically, for the fatty acid breakdown products of fat.
These are actually the nasties.
The researcher who demonstrated this is the easiest way to think about what they taste like is to imagine old rancid French fry oil.
It's gone off, and that's what fatty acids taste like.
Yeah, I definitely know that it's almost certainly one of those warning tastes to keep us away from rancid.
Speaker 1Fats, and is there anything good that can be done with it?
Speaker 4A little bit of these nasty, fatty acids are part of what makes aged cheese interesting, huh So yeah, and probably also a little bit in aged meat and things like that.
Yeah, So in very small quantities, you know, just like putting a little bit of cat in persum actually is a good thing.
You know, these nasties in our food probably do add interest if there's little enough of them.
Speaker 2You know.
Speaker 3One of the other things that you explained that I thought was super interesting is that humans get a bad wrap for having an inferior sense of smell.
So is this really a myth?
Speaker 4We have fewer odor receptors in our nose than it's something like a dog does, so they probably are better than us, but not nearly as much better than us as we think.
When people have looked, they found that humans are actually pretty good at smelling stuff.
A blindfolded person can follow on a chocolate trail across a lawn on their hands and he's sniffing to find where the chocolate was d So, you know, most of the reason that we think we're so bad at smell is that our noses are way up in the air and all the smells are down there on the ground.
So if we were to, if we were to explore our worlds just like our dogs do, we'd find there were stuff there we could smell.
People can go into a into a onto a bookshelf and pick out which book someone has just handled by the smell alone.
Speaker 3Wow.
Speaker 4And at the other place, we're really good at smell.
Actually, it's in flavor.
The shape of our heads mean that means the flavors foods that are inside our mouths have very quick access to the olfactory part of the nose, and so we're probably way better than our dogs are at appreciating flavor.
Speaker 3Mm hmm.
That's really interesting.
Speaker 1That's so crazy.
I mean, I feel like that totally changes the truffle game, like the truffle hunting game, Like you don't need a pig if you're on all four four.
Speaker 4That's probably right, right, that some people don't smell the key compound and truffles.
Speaker 3Yeah, I'd probably do it for the right bar of chocolate.
Yeah, yeah, all right.
Well, being an expert on flavor, we couldn't let you go without putting you to the test on an ultimate flavor quiz.
So, mango, what what game do we have?
What game do we have Bob playing today?
Speaker 1We're playing a game called vintage recipe or a gourmet cat food flavor.
Speaker 3That's right, So we'll be tossing you a delicious sounding item.
Delicious is in air quotes, which doesn't work quite as well on podcasts.
But you have to tell us if it's a vintage recipe we found online or a gourmet cat food flavor.
So you ready to get started?
Speaker 4Ready?
Speaker 1All right?
Speaker 3So the first one is ham and bananas, hollandais ham and bananas Holland days?
Is this a vintage recipe we found online or a gourmet cat food flavor.
Speaker 4I'm gonna go vintage.
Speaker 3Yeah, you would be right.
Speaker 1It's a great way to make use of your leftover bananas and ham apparently.
Speaker 3All right, Okay.
Number two Sea Bess in Seabas consumme.
Speaker 4I'm gonna go cat slicks for that one.
Speaker 1Yeah, you're right, it's from Tiki Cats Hawaiian queen Emma Luau line.
Speaker 3Of course, all right.
Question number three liver sausage, pineapple.
Speaker 4I can't imagine the cat eating pineapples.
I'm gonna go with vintage recipe.
Speaker 3Yeah, three for three.
I really probably would have guessed cat food on that though, just because the word liver would have thrown me off.
I think, all right, number four lime cheese salad is he correct?
Speaker 1Yeah, you're right, it's a It was a recipe from Jello and and it's a Yello bed with a seafood salad plopped on top.
Speaker 4I think I've had that Midwestern church suppers.
Speaker 3All right, we've got two left.
He's four for four so far.
Here we go.
Ocean fish, tuna and cheese sauce.
Speaker 4That sounds like it would appeal to a cat.
Speaker 1All right, it is a gourmet coffee.
I can't believe there's cheese sauce in Yeah, it's from the Tasty Treasures line.
Speaker 3Right, some fancy cat food.
All right, let's see if you can get six for six spam and limas spam and Lima's.
Speaker 4No recipes.
Speaker 1Wow.
Yeah, it was a promotional recipe from Hormel, and it had a Spanish gravy and frozen lime of beans.
Speaker 3That is incredible, So Bob, how has Bob done?
Speaker 1He ran the table.
He did won an incredible six for six, which wins him Today's grand prize, which is our endless admiration.
Speaker 3Wow, congratulations, Bob.
Speaker 4That is huge, Thank you kindly.
Speaker 3Yeah, well, Bob, thanks so much for writing a terrific book and for joining us today on Part Time Genius.
All right, guess what I've got my pocket here?
Mango?
Speaker 1Oh, that sounds so creepy.
Speaker 3Sorry, I should have I probably should have phrased that a little differently.
But guess what I have in my pocket here?
That rhymes with schmop blocks.
Speaker 1That sounds even creepier.
But you've got pop rocks, right.
Speaker 3I know we've talked about taste, smell, and touch and that those are considered the flavor trinity, but we can't leave out sound or other multisensory effects on how we experience flavor.
Speaker 1Well, you're gonna crack open those bad boys or not?
Speaker 3All right, let's do it.
They are so good.
Pop Rocks reminded me of that, you know, that part in the Eddie Hazard routine where he's talking about chiropractors and how they live for the noise, and that chiropracting or what do you call.
Speaker 1It, chiropractice cracking bones.
Speaker 3Would be nothing if they didn't hear the sound.
They're just like I live for the noise, I crack your bones.
So anyway, all right, you remember how our friend and former Mental Flaws editor, Ah, they pop rocks are still just popular, like crazyhood.
I don't think I've had one of these since I was ten.
I need more.
Okay, So you remember our friend and former Mental Flaws editor jess and Collins used to talk about chip o'clock in the office.
Speaker 1Yeah, for you listeners, there was a period in the mid afternoon when the editorial staff and Mental Flaws used to all go out for their afternoon snack and grab a bag of chips.
It made her crazy.
Speaker 3Well, while that sound may be difficult for the person not eating the chips to listen to, for the people eating chips, that sound likely increase their enjoyment.
So papers have shown that people rate chips is tastier if they provide a louder crunch.
It was even a study by Charles Spence and Maxampinie that had people eat one hundred and eighty pringles.
Speaker 1I'm so envious that people got to eat pringles for sign I.
Speaker 3Mean, we did get to have pop rocks and I kind of coke, and we got to watch Jerry have that bitter taste.
But as they did this, they wore headphones that played back the sound of their crunch, so as they work their way through the chips, the researchers adjusted the volume level of the crunch feedback, and they found that the louder crunching made them rate the chips fifteen percent tastier than the softer crunching.
Speaker 1I still can't believe they got to eat sprinkles for sign.
I I know the sound of an expensive coffee maker has been showed to increase how people rated a cup of Joe, But I also loved the study where Spence had a group of subjects eat oysters while listening to different sounds.
Some of them heard the sounds of waves and seagulls, and some of them heard sounds from barnyards like chickens clucking and cows mooing.
And not only did those who heard the sea sounds rate the oyster's tastier, they also experienced them as saltier.
Speaker 3I love this stuff because it kind of feels like food trickery.
But I guess as we understand that all our senses are involved in how we experience flavor, it's really no more trickery than anything else we do to enhance flavor.
So let's talk about some of the other multi sensory effects on flavor.
Speaker 1I love that music can affect how we experience flavor.
Like Holmes notes that really powerful music like Carl Orff's Carmina Burana causes people to note the heavier flavors in a red wine and what he describes as zingie music actually brings out the brighter flavors and a white wine.
And with that in mind, I'd like to recommend after the show we all listened to Holland Oates and neat a bag of rollos.
I bet that can only make the experience of both better.
Speaker 3And then we'll eat one of those Reese's Fast Break bars and listen to Aya the Tiger.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's science and action, folks.
We'll report back.
Speaker 3But there's some other fun and funny results of experiments, Like there was this Goldilock style experiments using three bowls of yogurt.
Yogurt was the same in all three bowls, but the bulls weighed different amount.
Speaker 1And how many bears were involved this is zero.
Speaker 3It wasn't published in our bear reviewed medical journals, but people did note that they enjoyed the yogurt in the heaviest bowl, most like, why should weight of a bowl affect your enjoyment?
And strawberry moose served on a white plate was rated sweeter than the same dessert served on a black plate.
Speaker 1One of my favorite studies was the one on hockey fans at Cornell, and researchers found that when the home team won, fans actually found the ice cream to be sweeter, and when they lost, they noted it as more sour.
How weird is that?
Speaker 3That's almost as sciencey as our science.
Speaker 1Okay, so if all these senses contribute to flavor, why do we only associate flavor with the stuff happening in our mouths?
Speaker 3Well, that's the work of our brains.
It takes all that information smell, taste, texture, sound and combines it into one experience, and then it tells us that experience is happening in our mouths.
So as a side note, many food scientists now say that while foods obviously contain flavor molecules, they believe the actual flavors themselves aren't created by the food, but instead by our brains.
Speaker 1Which I guess would be a big part of the reason why we all experience flavor differently.
Speaker 3That's just weird, yes it is.
But we are not done with our weird facts for the day.
You know what time it is.
It's time for the part time genius factos, the part of the show where we share some of the interesting facts we learned recently but didn't get a chance to mention just yet.
Speaker 1So Bill, why don't you start this round all right?
Speaker 3Sure?
So?
If you read airline mages, you often see that famous chefs pair up with airlines to improve the n flight meals, but the odds are stacked against them.
According to a study commission by the German airline carrier Lufthansa, between the elevation and the dryness that occurs in the cabin, your sensitivity to sweet and salty foods decreases by about thirty percent, which means the meal probably tastes a whole lot better if you save it for after you land.
Speaker 1Do you know?
Peanut butter and mayo sandwiches used to be a popular thing like According to Garden and Gun magazine, The sandwiches were a staple during the Depression and could be fancied up by adding a few leaves of lettuce and some pickles, and so the editors at food fifty two this other site, also tried the sandwich on reader recommendation, and their verdict was, if you wear a blindfold when you take a bite, it almost tastes like a tuna sandwich.
Speaker 3All right, why don't we just name a few odd recipes we've found since we both looked them up.
The Betty Crocker recommended a tuna and jello pie, also known as a summer.
Speaker 1Pie devoid the winter sales slump.
Doctor Pepper Wren ads that you should heat the soda in a saucepan and then poured over a lemon.
Gross which is why nothing reminds me of Christmas more than a steaming mug of Doctor Pepper.
Speaker 3Did you know that Johnny Walker makes a mustache wax that enhances their drinks.
The wax comes in three flavors, pepper, citrus, and ginger, and it helps to apply a generous amount to your stash.
Speaker 1So, I know, we talked about eating in texture today, but I learned this isn't a completely new concept.
In the nineteen thirties, the Italian futurists played with food and texture in a completely different way.
Diners were clothed in textured pajamas which they stroked with one hand in a dark room while burying their face and vegful.
What and when they looked up for their plates, a waiter which sprits them with perfume.
For some reason, the movement didn't take I.
Speaker 3Can't imagine why.
Speaker 1Yeah, futurists hated pasta, and they like to sculpt their meats.
And there was also one course where you ate salad out of a tiny box with one hand and turned a crank with the other.
As long as you were turning the crank, your waiter would dance for you.
Speaker 3That is so good.
I have to give you this one, so you earned this week's fact Off.
Speaking of which we need to nominate as smarty pants to our Hall of Genius.
I'm thinking we should give it to William Mitchell's family.
Mitchell was a food inventor who grew up on a farm, worked his way through college, and then went on to invent cool whip, powdered egg whites for cake mix, quickset, jello tang and.
Speaker 1That's so many amazing things and what.
Speaker 3And pop rocks.
Apparently the candy was supposed to be a carbonated drink mix, but it worked better as a crazy kids treat.
Speaker 1He's in William Mitchell's family.
You'll be getting a certificate in the mail and special thanks to our brilliant nonfiction librarians over at the Hoover Public Library in Hoover, Alabama for recommending the book Flavored by Bob Holmes.
If you like what you heard, be sure to pick up a copy today.
That's it for today's episode.
Thanks for listening.
Thanks again for listening to Part Time Genius.
Be sure to subscribe wherever you listen to your podcast.
Speaker 3And because we're a brand new show, if you're feeling extra generous, we'd love it if you give us a rating on Apple Podcasts.
Part Time Genius is produced by some of our favorite geniuses.
It's edited by Tristan McNeil, theme song and audio mixing by Noel Brown.
Our executive producer is Jerry Rowland.
Our research team is Gabe Lucier, Lucas Adams, Autumn white Field, Madrano, Austin Thompson, and Meg Robbins.
Jason Hope is our chief cheerleader.