Episode Transcript
Bloomberg Audio Studios, Podcasts, Radio News.
Welcome to Marin Talks Money, the podcast in which people who know the markets explain the markets.
I'm Meren Sunset Web.
This week, I want to focus in on a market that I think global portfolios are not paying enough attention to, Latin America.
I wrote a column a few weeks ago which I hope you all read, making the case for investors to think more actively about the region.
It's currently very cheap relative to more expensive markets such as the US in particular, and also cheap relative to much of the rest of the emerging markets universe.
There's a lot of good dividends around as well, and of course it's often passed up because it's categorized as an emerging market and all lumped together as one, and this of course is very misleading.
So in this episode are going to talk about the investment potential of Latin America.
And joining me to do that is Jose Manuel Silba, the chief investment officer and partner of laren Vial Asset Management, which is one of the leading investment houses in Chile.
Welcome Jose, Thank you so much for joining us today.
Speaker 2Thank you very much, joining good morning for us, good after for you, probably in for me.
Speaker 1Absolutely, we've got quite a lot to get through.
So let's just start, if you don't mind, by addressing this issue of the emerging markets categorization.
If you look up the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, you will find that in there you have Brazil named as sort of four point four percent of the index.
Nothing else in Latin America is mentioned at all.
It's all just under other, a little bit of lump of the other, nothing special in there.
And the question, of course is whether many of these markets should even be classified as emerging markets at all.
None of it really makes sense, does it.
Speaker 2Yeah, Because, for instance, in the emerging markets you have countries like Taiwan or South Korea which probably you define them as developed countries today.
And additionally, of course it's a categorization which mixes countries with very different type of microeconomic and microeconomic settings.
Companies or countries which are very related to Asia, to China, to the Chinese microeconomic I would say cycle, some other countries which are much more related to the European economic cycle, and others much more related to the US economic cycle.
Countries which produce technology.
After the countries produce a lot of commodities.
But really you are mixing there a lot of different countries, and actually even in the Latin universe you have quite a mix of countries and different types of I would say macro and microeconomic settings.
Speaker 1And there's also the sense, isn't it that if something is an emerging market, it comes with weak institutions and almost the sense of some kind of political chaos or volatility.
And that is something that one may in the past have associated with Latin mimer.
There's political volatility all over the place, but at the moment you look around the world and we've got a bastion in stability here.
Speaker 2Yeah, what happens is, luckily the developed world has become more volatile, I would say in terms of institutions, some of the institutions that have made the developed world what it is are I would say, under attack those four apps that Professor Neil Ferguson always says that the Western world downloaded so that the Western world became what it is now.
Probably a lot of people are doubting if it was a good idea to download those apps, which I think is a bigger or to have that idea.
But really, and on this hand that the emerging market countries, many of them have been doing quite a lot of reforms in the last thirty four years, twenty five years.
That's the case of America, but also that's what you see in Asia.
Some of those countries are growing a lot and are improving the institutions a lot.
In many ways, they still have weak in situations, but I would say the gap between the spe quality spread between institutions between the developed world and the emerging market world have closen, yeah, very much.
So twenty years I would say.
Speaker 1Yeah, while we're talking about political stability, let's have a quick talk about the United States trumps America and how that affects the region as a whole.
We might come onto more specific countries in our relationships with the US no of course, for China later, but as an overall view, how does Trump's America affect the relationship with Latin America.
Speaker 2It's difficult to say, because on the one hand, of course, you see a United States which in a way it's closing on itself or probably after many many years where the United States was the guy that led the globalization process and led institutions that in a way, the developidation tours.
You know, all agreement after the World War, you know, the gap agreements and now called WTO and how the US led the world after the Berlin World fell.
All of that is under I would say attack.
Now in the US.
Probably it's true that there's a part of the US middle class that was under heavy attack by Asian competition.
So probably that those people are a bit angry under wages and under instability, and so in a way one feels that the US is closing itself, you know.
It's there's a book which is called the Closing of the American Mind by HOWD Blumer.
We could call this the closing of the American market.
Speaker 1Yeah, this could be a positive in some ways for Latin America because from America is pulling back from the wider world that's pulling back into the Americas.
Speaker 2Yes, that's true.
That's for instance.
That's why what our partner Leuvan Song gav have suggested for some years now.
He talks about Fort Monroe, you know, relating this to the Monroe Doctrine, which was this rectrem in the nineteenth century who said America's to the Americans, you know, so keep the European powers out of the America.
And in a way now the US is saying we should perhaps retreat to this fortress, you know, fortress America.
They talk about the Western world, and there was involved for them is all of the Americas.
And for instance, Predident Trump appointed a point and first minister.
He's a Latin, Marco Rubio.
He is married to a Columbian lady.
He knows very well Latin America.
He's a friend of many politicians in the region.
He's second in command.
Also was a former ambassador to Mexico, and when he was a young guy, he was the son of the ambassador, the US ambassador in Chile, in Venezuela and Paraguay.
So he's also a guy that knows perfectly well what's happening in the region.
So for the first time you have a team inside the White House that really knows Latin America and knows the process, the minuses who is who and so why would to say that the US will try to enhance its relationship with Latin America, especially its economic relationship.
Well, the US has already signed retrade agreements with several Latin American countries.
The first one was the Chillian one, but not the only one now, So I would say that the US, probably if it wants to retreat from the rest of the world, needs in a way Latin America needs.
Latin America's markets, needs its Latin America's demography needs Latin America's commodities.
This could be the beginning of interesting times for Latin America.
I agree with that.
Speaker 1And it also one more thing you didn't mention in that list was Latin America's high end manufacturing abilities.
So Mexico, for example, is turning itself into a high end manufacturing hub.
Speaker 2Or we talk about.
Speaker 1Friend sharing and close shoring, and Mexico is the obvious home for that kind of maney for sure.
Speaker 2And actually one of the interesting things about that in America is that in a way you have had thirty years of economic reform.
Really the microeconomic reforms began in Chile in the seventies, eighties and nineties with what they called the Chicago Boys.
You know, it was a free market reform, the regulation, privatization, opening up the economy.
Many other lat the American countries copied Chile was the case of Peru, partially Colombia in a way partially Mexico too, because of the success, Chile became a laggard in the region in the seventies and became one of the wealthiest countries in the region in the late nineties and during the first decades of this century.
So countries followed that path, and even the two giants the region, you know, Mexico and Brazil, have reformed a lot of their institutions, especially macro institutions, so they have now central banks which are quite independent.
In the case of Brazil, you don't have hyperinflation anymore.
In the case of Mexico neither.
The last country probably to have hyperinflation was Argentina, and it seems that with President Milay they are away controlling the beasts, the fiscal beasts and the hyperinflation beasts.
So in a way for the US it makes a lot of sense to integrate more with this region.
But this, as you mentioned, part of this reform is that some countries, especially Mexico and Brazil, have now very high end manufacturing activity.
But you have the carry industry of course in Mexico, but for instance, in Brazil you have a company like Embraer which produces airplanes, and they produce commercial airplanes that are gaining market sail all over the world, and they actually they are benefiting from the problems from Boyling and partially Airbostole.
Now they are selling actually a military transport airplane to NATO countries Embryer.
So really you have very interesting industrial companies in the region.
Speaker 1Yeah, then you have one thing that we haven't mentioned yet is a slightly lower level of debt risk than you might have and some what we consider to be very developed countries.
So debt to GDP ratios across Latin America are slightly lower than elsewhere.
And I think is it highest in Brazil.
The high in Brazil eighty percent, but others are below that.
When you think that, you know, UK is one hundred and other western countries are well over that.
That's slightly reasering too.
Speaker 2Yeah, Chile has around forty percent, Mexico is fifty percent, Columbia sixty percent, Rules thirty five percent of GDP.
So really, it's true that one of the main reforms that Latin America has done in the last thirty years is was called the macro reforms with these independent central banks thanks to privatizations all over the place.
Because we have had privatizations from Mexico to the Cave Horn.
And because of that, now physcal deficits are more controlled because in the past, part of the physical defic it's where due to financing state owned companies, you know, and now many of those companies have been privatized.
They are very productive companies, or they are partially privatized, and that's the case of companies like Eco Patrol, the oil producing company in Colombia, or Petro Bras in Brazil, you know, Brazil.
Very few people realize that Brazil is becoming an oil giant.
Today.
Brazil is the largest oil producing country in Latin America.
And now not only Brazil is self sufficient in oil, which was not the case forty years ago, but Brazil is becoming a large exporter of oil.
And it's partially done by Petro Brass, but also by new private, mid sized private companies in the oil industry.
Some of those companies, we invest in them and in their bonds and their inequities.
And it's very interesting what's happening in Brazil in the oil field.
Speaker 1And this is really interesting because one of the criticisms that has been made historically of Latin American economies is that they have failed somehow to proper monetized their enormous natural resources.
So you know, so many Latin American countries are so rich and everything from copper to oil, to lithium, etc.
But somehow it hasn't quite been monetized properly.
So Brazil and oil turns out to be a positive way forward for that.
And then of course as we move through the energy transition, or we attempt to move through the energy transition, and electricity demand goes up, then all these other metals wearers, and Latin America is very rich and weres become an extraordinary resource that with a stable economic background, can be much better monetized than in the past.
Speaker 2Yeah, they're actually, to be honest, once again, the poster child in the region in terms of monetization of mineral resources.
For Chile, Chili created a very pro market and pro private property mining law in the late seventies early eighties that produced a boom in exploration and then a boom in copper production that allowed Chile to become the largest copper producer in the world and Peruna is the second largest copper producer in the world.
Chile also produces a lot of lithium.
Speaker 1As i'spayed some fastson there about let'sium mining and the environmental problems.
Speaker 2Lithium in Chile is extracted from what they call the brines, those are salt lakes in the desert.
The same thing will happen in Argentina actually, and probably impartially in Bolivia.
Bolivia is a country that probably has less monetized its natural resources.
But in the case of Argentina, once again, what's happening there is very interesting because Argentina is beginning to monetize it's lithium wealth, it's mineral wealth, but also it's oil wealth.
Argentina discovered a few years ago very large shale oil and shale gas deposit called Vacamuerta, and even the Kishners allowed the developer of that deposited because they realized that Argentina couldn't afford not to develop it.
And Argentina also is very very rapidly becoming the second largest gas and oil produced producing country in Latin America, and probably in the next few years Vacamuerta deposit will become a huge, huge exporter of gas for Argentina.
Speaker 1Interesting.
So we have this region with this stableish economic environment, stable age, political environment, high end manufacturing, rising middle class, massive resource potential.
So it kind of sounds perfect and you can get it across the board on a valuation significantly lower than as family average pe across Latin America or something like nine times.
Speaker 2Right, we have risks, We have political risks.
There is still a left wing in American sector.
Actually, we just had primaries for the left in Chile and it was the Communist party Candya that won the primaries with very low participation of people, et cetera, et cetera, but it was the Communist party that one.
So you say, well, there is a risk, but the risk in a way is embedded invaluation, because we are talking that among emerging markets, Latin America is trading probably one or one half standard deviation below the average of the last twenty five years compared to emerging markets, which themselves are trading at the very low multiples compared to developed especially in the US.
So really a lot of bad news are embedded in Latin American asset prices, equity prices, but also you know interest rates.
For instance, there is another asset class which is very less well known, is latinm corporate credit.
In heart currency.
You know, we manage a fund that invests in Latin art currency bonds.
So those are bonds issued by the blue chips all over the region that issue bonds offshore using you do it in dollars, and those are bonds which have a current deal of around eight percent dollar dominated.
And I always say that you have their sort of a restrating arbitrash because these are cambris which if they had their headquarters in Miami, they would be classified as an investment grade.
But since they have their headquarters in South Paolo or in something or Bogota, they are high yield.
Yes, you have a lot of assets which are very interesting training at low multiples or high yields.
So with a lot of add news and budded enter prices and with a you, I would say good stories, you know, good company stories, good macro stories.
Probably people have a lot of investors don't realize the interesting things that that happen year.
Speaker 1Let's talk a little bit about how you invested and where you invest at my fun fact of the day that someone told me this morning, as it only takes an hour longer to fly from London to South Paler than from Power to Mexico City, so you know you are covering an insanely large area when it comes to looking at companies, and your website tells me that the company that you fund managers are visiting two hundred companies a year, so you must be spending most of your life on an aeroplane, are you?
How are you choosing companies to invest in?
Speaker 2Yeah, we use several techniques, O say.
First, of course, we try to know very deeply the region, so we travel a lot.
We have a lot of also a network of friends, i would say now at the end of the days, all over the regions.
So we have been vesting in the region for the last forty fifty years.
Lambia my company has ninety years history, so we have been helping Chileans invest in the region for many, many years.
Of course, we have the advantage of the language, so even if it's a very huge market in terms of hours over the plane, we most of us speak Spanish or Portuguese or port tool which is sort of a blend between the Brazilian Portuguese and our Spanish, so we we tend to understand ourselves, so we have a sort of a common culture, even if it's the mex Mexicans are very different from Chileans, and Chili's are very different from Peruvians and Colombians, but we have the same language.
Then of course we use a very sophisticated i would say quant model to get new ideas and control risk.
And so with the quant model, we see what are the i would say most interesting companies all over the region, and then we travel.
You know, we have our analysts are located mostly in Santiago.
We have some analysts in Lima, some analysts now in Argentina too, but we travel a lot and also a lot of Latin American companies come to Santiago.
Santiago has become sort of a pension pub you know, Chile has around three hundred and fifty billion dollars in pension funds undermanaged.
Speaker 1Recently been some significant reforms to depends and system in Chile right which means that there should be going forward significantly higher flows into the actual market.
Speaker 2And in Mexico.
That's another interesting thing that has happened in the last I would say thirty years, is that for the first time in latinin history, you have local investors in local currency which are investing for the long term.
For instance, in the past, when a Latin blue chip needed money, they needed to issue in dollars, because it didn't they couldn't issue bonds locally.
Now in many of our markets, Mexico, Peru, Chile, Brazil, you have an internal, wide developed bond market in local currency, which is the biggest investors are institutional investors, and that has helped a lot in terms of reducing the risk, the macroeconomic risk, because the typical microeconomic risk that Lat'm facing the past is that suddenly you have commodities coming down to price and so the effects you know, the currency is devalued, but you also had a lot of external debt government and also corporations.
Now you still have volatility in the prices of commodities.
That's normal.
Part of the death of local corporates, of local banks and local government is issued in local currency, which.
Speaker 1Must have been helpful for Mexico and Brazil last year because both so that currency is weakened substantially.
Speaker 2That's right, that's right, And in the case of Chile to Perutu, today I would say the cost of capital of many of local corporates is lower than in the past.
If you consider that now they do not need to hedge their external debt because they are issuing bonds in the local markets and that's helping a lot.
Speaker 1Quite not about Argentina, but can you imagine any of your funds investing in Argentina because they don't at the moment, you don't hold Argentina and equity.
Speaker 2Well, we know, we invest, especially in Latin Argentina's bonds, corporate bonds, and those are dollar denominated corporate bonds.
So we have core bonds of companies like YPF, you know, the oil producer in Argentina, the one that is producing the oil in Baca Guerta, or another oil producing companies like Pampa or Vista.
Lately, we are beginning, especially since we realize that the Milai reforms are going on track.
They're working, they're working.
We are beginning very slowly to invest in some equities.
Additionally, what happens is that you have some Latin American companies, especially the Chilian ones, that have Argentina and assets which until now they were valued at ero.
So you have a company in Chile called Senkosuits, one of the largest retailers in Latin America.
They are in supermarket, hypermarket department stores, do it yourself stores, and they are one of the leading companies in all those fields in Chile, in Peru, in Colombia.
They even have a high end supermarket in the States.
But probably in the mid nineties, one of the largest assets of sen Cosut was Argentina and they still have it.
They still have it.
The problem is that in the last twenty years investors have said, Okay, we're going to value those assets in Argentina ero.
We don't count on them now that Argentina is going up.
These guys have a huge supermarket hypermarket business in Argentina, they have a do it yourself retail stores in Argentina, they have males in Argentina, and actually when you buy the Argentina ETF, you are buying also sen Cosuit, for instance, the co Oak Butler in Santiago, which also has a huge position in Argentina.
Once again, in the past everybody said, okay, let's consider those Argentina and assets as valueless.
You know, they're worthless, so we're not going to value and both the Yao and Dina that's the name of the company, which also has bottling operations in Brazil and in Paraguay.
But now suddenly the boatling operations in Argentina are beginning to be valued, so you.
Speaker 1Can get access to the Argentinian market without having to buy an equations in Argentina.
Speaker 2Sorry, you have a company like Medcaalo Liver.
Mercalo Liver is the largest e commerce company in Latin America.
Actually it was founded by Argentinians, which shows Argentinians have an incredible human capital resource.
All over Wall Street is full of Argentinians.
You know.
Merkelo Liver was founded by our Argentina entrepreneurs.
It's located in the US, so that it's incorporated in the US under US law.
But now it's the largest e commerce company all over the region in Latin America, and it has huge operations in Argentina.
Once again, if Argentina begins to go up to grow to consume market, delivery will enjoy a lot.
What will happen in Argentina.
Speaker 1Do you have a favorite market among the other main markets in Latin America.
You live in Chile.
Speaker 2One of the advantages of living in Chile is that we do not have Brazilian home bias or the Mexican home bias.
But since we're the smallest country of all of the large ones in Latin America.
We have to invest in Brazil, we have to invest in Argentina, we have to invest in Mexico.
And in a way more than being a lot of a country in itself or a market, we try to fall in love with companies and we find incredible companies in Mexico, in Brazil, now in Argentina, to in Peru, you have very good companies.
The market is smaller in prou less liquid, but you have an incredible bank like the Creditor Peru, which is a very very well run bank.
You have good stories, you know, in the retail sector in Peru.
You have good banks in Colombia too.
We are a very bottom uped house.
We do a lot of research.
We try to really meet all the companies with the senior management.
We build very sophisticated I would say evaluation models.
So in a way we try to fall in love companies.
Speaker 1Everyone hates it when I asked this question.
Everyone hates to have to peck one.
But if you're falling in love with a company, what are you most in love with at the moment?
Speaker 2We like very much mercaal Oliberty.
You know, this e commerce giant in Latin America.
We like their growth, We like what they're doing in the fintech area.
We like also Empire, you know, the industrial giant in Brazil which builds very good quality planes.
Also is in the defense area.
But we like also commodity producing companies like Petro Brass.
You know, Petro Brass has an incredible dividend yield, it growing.
You know what is the yield the tough one today Paturize is probably yielding between eight and nine percent per year.
Lovely, our portfolio is yielding around six percent, so you have yield in Latin American you know, a divon yield.
There is a bunch of companies that yield more than ten percent.
Now, our portfolio have a mix of high devn yielders and also high growth like Mercaaloibri would be a high growth company.
Also a very interesting internet bank called new Bank.
New Bank now is a huge bank in Brazil.
It's entering the Mexican market.
It's entering also the Argentinian market.
So you have also technological companies in the region.
You have a company called Totus in Brazil which is an ERP you know, enterprise reserve, especially for mid sized companies.
You have very good quality industrial companies.
You know, we have two funds.
You know, we have a large LUGP fund, but also we have a small meatcap and ditricity.
With a small meatcap fund is that you have less less commodities, less banks, and more industrial companies, more healthcare.
You have a very interesting companies in the healthcare.
So really with so strange, Yeah, we have most of the sectors present in the index.
Speaker 1Brilliant.
Well, I think you probably convinced everybody that's to do it.
You mentioned the book earlier, the closing of the American Mind.
Are you a agree?
What are you reading at the moment?
Speaker 2Oh?
Well, I am reading a book about Bob Francis, which was written by Javier Circa with a very famous Spanish author.
Speaker 1Turns great, we'll put that on everyone summer reading less.
Thank you very very much, indeed, we really appreciate you coming on.
Speaker 2Thankre Maturin, and I hope I convinced someone to get a view in the region.
Speaker 1Thanks for listening to this week Marin Jog's Money.
If you like us a rate review and subscribe by every listening to podcast and keep sending questions or comments Marimani at Bloomberg dot net.
You can also follow me and John on Twitter or x.
I'm at marianeess w and John is John Underscores Epect.
This episode was hosted by me Marin Suset Web, produced by Samasadi and special thanks, of course to host it.