The Horsewhipped Reverend & The House of Miss Johnson

April 22
12 mins

View Transcript

Episode Description

In this episode of Turlock Unburied, we uncover two unforgettable local stories—one ripped from newspaper headlines, the other whispered through neighborhood legend.

First, we revisit the shocking 1908 scandal of Reverend James Hilbish, the anti-saloon preacher publicly horsewhipped and beaten on Main Street after accusing women tied to the Palm Restaurant of vice and liquor dealing. The assault divided Turlock and made headlines across California.

Then, we step into The House of Miss Johnson—the unsettling memory of a legendary local teacher whose darkened home, strange reputation, and disturbing artwork left a lasting mark long after the house itself was gone.

A tale of public outrage, private mystery, and two sides of old Turlock few have forgotten.


Audio Credits:

A complete list of source credits can be found on turlockunburied.com

See all episodes