Lucy McCarraher of BookMagic AI – Using AI to Write Your Book (Without AI Writing Your Book)

Nov 11, 2025
47 mins

Episode Description

Lucy McCarraher is the founder of Rethink Press (a hybrid publisher specializing in business books) and BookMagic AI (an AI-assisted writing platform). Over 12 years, she has mentored over 2,000 entrepreneurs and business leaders through the book-writing process, making her the UK's most experienced business book mentor. Lucy's background spans theatre publishing in Australia, creating "video books" with celebrities like Prue Leith and Alan Titchmarsh, and pioneering work-life balance consulting. She has authored 13 books herself and developed a systematic process for helping non-writers transform their expertise into published books. Her philosophy: books should be "undercover sales agents," not marketing brochures—providing real value while building authority and credibility.


In this episode:

  • The three P's: person, pain, promise positioning
  • BookMagic AI's values exercise starting point
  • Breaking writing into discrete, manageable stages
  • Why AI shouldn't generate your actual book content
  • Copyright concerns with AI-generated text
  • Using AI for research and ideas, not writing
  • The one-hour-early writing habit strategy
  • Dictation feature for non-writers and dyslexic authors
  • Planning every topic before you start writing
  • Writing to one ideal reader, not a crowd
  • AI-generated blog posts and social media content
  • Why publishers reject AI-generated manuscripts
  • Hybrid publishing vs. DIY self-publishing costs
  • Distribution beyond Amazon KDP
  • Multiple formats don't reduce sales
  • Future features: end-to-end publishing in-app


Resources mentioned:


Book recommendations:


Connect with Lucy:


Connect with Teddy Smith:

Support the show

Discover More with Our Curated Starter Packs: https://teddyagsmith.com/starter-packs/



See all episodes