How to Lead When Your Church Board is Divided

January 21
22 mins

Episode Description

Board meetings going nowhere? Two members dug in on opposite sides? Today we tackle one of the most common—and most damaging—situations church leaders face: how to actually lead when your board is divided. Learn to diagnose the real issue, make decisions without unanimity, and prevent division through clear authority structures.

Scott Ball and A.J. Mathieu are church consultants with The Malphurs Group, specializing in helping churches navigate leadership challenges, strategic planning, and revitalization. Through practical frameworks and real-world experience, they equip pastors and church leaders with actionable solutions for building healthy, thriving congregations.

In This Episode:
[1:11] Diagnose the Division: Understanding directional vs. relational conflict
[8:45] Lead to a Decision: Why unity doesn't mean unanimity
[15:42] Prevent Division by Clarifying Authority: Setting boundaries before conflict
[21:40] Next Steps: Resources for healthy board leadership

Links & Resources:

  • 📖 Read the full article: malphursgroup.com/324
  • 🎁 🎓Building a Biblical Board Course available in the Healthy Churches Toolkit Free 7-Day Trial: healthychurchestoolkit.com
  • 📱 Connect with us on Facebook: facebook.com/malphursgroup
  • Instagram: instagram.com/malphursgroup
  • YouTube: youtube.com/themalphursgroup
  • X/Twitter: x.com/malphursgroup

 

See all episodes

Never lose your place, on any device

Create a free account to sync, back up, and get personal recommendations.