In this episode, numismatist David McCarthy joins to explore the fascinating world of pioneer gold coins — their history, types, key figures, and how they fit into the broader collector landscape. Perfect for enthusiasts eager to understand these rare pieces and how to approach collecting them.

Main Insights:
David McCarthy’s background and expertise is in American numismatics, focusing on pioneer gold coins.
The origins of private and semi-official gold coins in the United States, dating back to the late 18th and early 19th centuries.
Clarification of terminology: why "territorial gold" is a misnomer, and why "pioneer gold" or "private gold" are more accurate.
Key historical figures such as Ephraim Brasher, Templeton Reid, and the Bechtler family, with insights into their coin-making contributions.
The significance of early private gold coins like the Brasher doubloon as some of the earliest in North America.
How private coins depicted in the discussion, like the California gold rush pieces, reflect the tumult and innovation of their era.
The complexities of the market, including rarity, value, and the influence of provenance.
Notable examples such as the Moffatt & Company ingots, and their story within the California gold rush.
Challenges of authentication, conservation, and valuation in pioneer gold collectibles.
Resources for collectors, including recommended literature and tips on working with specialists.

Timestamps:
00:00 Introduction to Pioneer Gold Coins
06:09 Understanding the Misnomer: Territorial vs. Pioneer Gold
10:53 The Brasher Doubloon: The First Private Gold Coin
15:01 The Value and Rarity of Pioneer Gold Coins
22:48 Mormon Gold Coins: A Unique Piece of History
28:41 Oregon Gold Coins: The Oregon Exchange Company
32:31 Norris, Gregg & Norris: The First California Gold Coins
36:50 Miners Bank: The Impact of Fire on Coinage
41:08 The Impact of Miners Bank's Fire
45:44 Researching California's Gold Economy
47:55 Moffat's Transition to the Assay Office
48:55 The Rarity of Ormsby Coins
51:09 The Mystery of Pacific Company Coins
53:10 The Design Influences on California Coins
55:07 End of Part 1

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: tony@cabbagecoins.com
IG: @cabbage_coins

New to the podcast? 
Click the  "Subscribe" Button

Intro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

Come to the Central States Numismatics Society Show:
April 23-25, 2026
Table 1717