Beyond Category: How Three Music Writers Navigate a Genre-Fluid World

Oct 6, 2025
37 mins

Episode Description

Michelle Zeto, Geoffrey Himes, and Rob Shepherd have each built careers in music journalism and broadcasting. They discuss how genre categories shape both criticism and listening, the difference between being a savant and a polymath, and whether the post-genre world is liberating or limiting. The conversation explores the role of critics as translators, the rise of playlist culture, and why attention spans may not be as new a problem as we think.

In this episode, we explore: 

  • How musicians themselves often resist the "jazz" label—and what that means for writers 
  • Why shorter attention spans might not be the crisis we think 
  • The tension between consumer advisor and cultural translator 
  • What human curation offers that algorithms can't 
  • Whether broad knowledge serves critics better than deep specialization

Learn more about our guests:

Our host:

And our organization, the Jazz Journalists Association




Don’t miss new episodes of The Buzz. Make sure you follow us wherever you listen to podcasts.

For more from the Jazz Journalists Association, go to JJANews.org.

See all episodes