Episode Description
This week, the Band Dads tackle a topic that might make some people a little uncomfortable… What do you do if you have a bad band director?
Before anyone jumps to conclusions, Scott and Chris take a thoughtful and fair approach by breaking the idea of a “bad” band director into three very different categories:
- A new educator still trying to find their footing
- A director who may struggle in a specific area that parents and boosters could help support
- A truly bad situation—where the environment or leadership is genuinely harmful for students and the program
From there, the conversation gets real.
Who is actually responsible when things go wrong? When conflict arises, do you automatically side with your child… or the director? How should parents evaluate situations fairly before emotions take over?
Scott puts Chris on the spot with his personal litmus test for handling difficult interactions with educators, which leads to the debut of the “Flynnrific Rubric™”—a surprisingly practical and level-headed framework for determining whether a situation is truly serious or simply the natural friction that can happen in high-pressure activities like band.
The episode becomes even more personal when Scott shares a firsthand experience involving his own son and a band director he believed was genuinely bad for students. Rather than simply venting, he walks listeners through the exact steps he took to pursue resolution in a productive and responsible way.
This episode is honest, practical, and full of real-world advice—not just for band, but for navigating difficult leadership relationships anywhere in life. It’s a nuanced conversation about accountability, communication, fairness, and ultimately doing what’s best for kids.
We want to here from you! Send us an email to: feedback@banddadspodcast.com
Check out these links to connect with us further!