The New York Mets just had one of the most painful weeks in recent franchise history. Pete Alonso is gone. Edwin Díaz is gone. The Winter Meetings offered more questions than answers. And now the fanbase is demanding clarity on what the plan actually is. On this week’s episode of Straight Outta Flushing: Andrew Claudio of ‘Just Mets’ joins the show to break down the Mets’ decision-making, what losing Alonso and Díaz really means, whether Jorge Polanco moves the needle, the future of the rotation, and how much trust fans should have in David Stearns’ long-term vision. Plus, ‘Why Am I A Mets Fan?’ co-host Ashley Wenskoski helps unpack the emotional state of Mets fandom right now: frustration, confusion, disappointment, and whether fans feel connected to this version of the team. How do Mets fans process losing two cornerstone players in 48 hours? And what, if anything can restore confidence? If you’re a Mets fan trying to make sense of this offseason, you’re not alone. Let’s talk through where the Mets go from here and whether there’s any reason for optimism.

(00:00) Intro

(00:50) Dugout Discussions with Andrew Claudio

(35:45) Dugout Discussions with Ashley Wenskoski