The conversation moves from Card Ladder and comps into a bigger, uncomfortable question: is opening modern product basically gambling, and what kind of culture do we actually want in the hobby going forward?

Jeremy, Chris McGill (HoJ), and Josh Adams dig into group breaks, pack odds, “hits,” and the reality that some collectors have gone bankrupt chasing boxes. They balance that against the fun and nostalgia of ripping with kids, Tim Hortons packs, and building sets the way many of us did in the 80s and 90s.

Along the way they tackle advertising, culture, and where the hobby goes next.

Topics in this segment include:
• PSA upcharges, comps, and why some people think PSA should have to buy your card at the value they assign
• Arena Club criticism, “where collecting begins” marketing, and whether repack-centric products are aimed more at gamblers than collectors
• Is opening any sealed product gambling, or does it depend on intent, price point, and expected return?
• Pack odds, box price vs expected value, and why the emotional hit of losing on wax feels exactly like losing at the casino for some people
• Breakers, gamblers, and the argument that the hobby “needs” high-volume product rippers to create singles for everyone else
• Direct-to-consumer vs LCS distribution and whether cards should always come from packs or could one day go straight to auction
• Getting more women in the hobby and how to treat everyone at shows as collectors first
• What kind of culture shift the hobby actually needs: less divisiveness, more mutual understanding, more integrity from individuals and institutions, and less “my way is the only right way”
• Leadership, voting with your wallet, and why content and conversations matter in shaping where the hobby goes next

Sports Cards Live streams live on YouTube every Saturday night, and this audio comes from that live video show.

If you enjoy the podcast, please follow, subscribe, and leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and check out the full video replays on the Sports Cards Live YouTube channel.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices