Today’s guests are Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty, the stars of the Broadway musical “Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York).” The show is a joyful, funny, and heartwarming story about chance encounters, unlikely connections, and one unforgettable day in New York City.

Christiani and Sam join host Jessie Sheehan to talk about their journeys to Broadway, what it’s like to carry an entire show as a two-person cast, and why “Two Strangers” has been described as a love letter to NYC. They also dive into the role cake plays in the show (yes, there is a real cake), the production’s partnership with Magnolia Bakery, and their personal dessert favorites—from red velvet cake to banana pudding to caterpillar cakes. 

"Two Strangers" audio clip courtesy of "Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)"

Order The Cake Issue
Pre-order our Galentine’s Day Issue
Bombesquad Bazaar tickets here
Jubilee NYC 2026 tickets here

Visit cherrybombe.com for subscriptions, tickets to upcoming events, and more.

More on Christiani: Instagram
More on Sam: Instagram
More on “Two Strangers”: Instagram
Get tickets to the show

More on Jessie: Instagram, “Salty, Cheesy, Herby, Crispy Snackable Bakes” cookbook