Why Do I Still Feel Broke When I Make Good Money?

September 1
20 mins

Episode Description

Making good money and still feeling broke isn't a math problem — it's a signal that your money has drifted out of line with your values.

Most people who feel financially anxious on a solid income assume the fix is earning more. It almost never is. This episode unpacks why the feeling of scarcity survives every raise, and how to find where it's actually coming from — so you can stop white-knuckling the one strategy that was never going to work.

What you'll discover:

  • The difference between "actual broke" (the math genuinely doesn't work) and "felt broke" (the numbers are fine but the anxiety won't leave) — and why you can't out-earn the second one
  • Why the raise feels huge for two weeks and ordinary by next quarter: hedonic adaptation and the goalpost drawn in disappearing ink
  • Money scripts — the beliefs about money you absorbed in childhood and never signed off on — and why "money vigilance" makes you great with money and anxious about it at the same time
  • What the 2023 Kahneman–Killingsworth study actually found about income and happiness (it's not the "$75k plateau" headline)
  • The three-layer check for locating where your "broke" feeling really lives: the math, the script, the values
  • A two-week practice that maps your money to your values without a single budgeting app

Q: Why do I still feel broke when I make good money?

A: Because financial security past a certain point is a feeling, not a number — and that feeling is usually driven by a goalpost that moves every time you hit it, money beliefs you inherited early, or spending that's out of line with what you actually value. More income rarely touches any of those three.

Q: Does earning more money reduce financial anxiety?

A: Up to the point where real strain is eased, yes. Beyond that, more income is a surprisingly weak lever on how secure your life feels. If a bigger number were going to fix the feeling, it usually would have by now.

Q: What is a money script?

A: A money script is a mostly unconscious belief about money you picked up as a child by watching the adults around you. Psychologist Brad Klontz identified four; two — money worship and money vigilance — most often explain feeling broke on a good income.

This episode is part of the optYOUmize Money & Financial Wellbeing series — exploring money as a tool for freedom, not a scoreboard for your worth.

Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or YouTube. https://optyoumize.com If this episode was useful, a quick review helps more people find the show: https://ratethispodcast.com/optyoumize

If you've been wrestling with money anxiety despite a good income, the question of how much is actually enough, or why lifestyle inflation quietly eats every raise, this is a conversation worth your time.

See all episodes