Valentine's Day is fast approaching, and the debate over who pays is heating up. Nick sits down with relationship expert Dr. Laura Berman and singer Toni Romiti to discuss whether the holiday is unfair to men. The conversation gets wild when a listener asks for advice about a boyfriend who refuses to use protection, prompting Toni to suggest the pull-and-pray method while Dr. Laura tries to keep things safe.

They also discuss the myth of unconditional love in romantic relationships, and Nick and Dr. Laura share a story about the time he accidentally messed up Valentine’s Day big time with his baby mamas.

Later, the group answers a question about a partner who insists on a red wig in the bedroom, and whether having no social media is a sign of a cheater. Finally, Nick hits the streets to see what women expect on Valentine’s Day, before Nick reveals his own strategy for surviving the season: being out of town.