Sgt. Betsy Brantner Smith sits down with former NYPD sergeant and cold case expert Joseph Giacalone, an investigator who turned “retirement” into a second career in media, teaching, and true crime storytelling.

From leading Bronx cold case homicide investigations to educating the public on the realities behind crime, Giacalone shares hard-earned insights on solving decades-old murders, working with prosecutors, and the growing national fascination with true crime.

Giacalone describes cold cases as investigations where all viable leads have been exhausted—which can happen in weeks or years.

Unlike TV portrayals:

Detectives must convince prosecutors to accept a case
Even strong evidence (including DNA) may be deemed insufficient
Prosecutors often demand additional evidence months after initial review

Solving a long-dormant homicide delivers:

A surge of adrenaline and fulfillment
Closure for victims’ families
A sense of justice delayed—but not denied

Building “True Crime with the Sarge”

Giacalone launched his podcast after years of media appearances and academic work.

His approach:
Combines real investigative experience + academic expertise
Offers both YouTube live shows and audio-only interviews
Listens closely to audience feedback to shape content

He fills a unique niche by bridging:

Street-level policing
Academic criminal justice
Media analysis

https://x.com/joegiacalone
https://www.josephgiacalone.com
https://www.youtube.com/josephgiacalone
https://www.facebook.com/JosephLGiacalone