What are the odds? In the world of true crime, that question can mean everything. Or perhaps nothing at all.

Two women named Mary Morris are murdered four days apart on the same stretch of road. A son gives a stranger a ride home, only to find that stranger may have killed his mother. A machete murder in Saint Augustine leads to a second suspicious death, and a book that someone desperately didn’t want written. A Florida swamp legend and a vanished judge share a web of names that seem too tangled to be accidental. And two young Atlanta women, same bank, same desk, same anonymous bouquet of roses, disappear two years apart under eerily similar circumstances.

Coincidence is everywhere if you look hard enough. But so is conspiracy.

In this episode of Haunts & Hollows: True Tales of the Gothic South, we untangle some of the South’s most baffling cold cases, the ones where the clues don’t just point to a killer, they point to each other. The question isn’t whodunit, it’s whether these chilling parallels mean anything at all.

Sometimes the most unsettling answer is “Maybe.”

Haunts & Hollows: True Tales of the Gothic South is the podcast for anyone who yearns for stories of haunted plantations, of deals made at midnight crossroads, of creatures lurking in moss-draped cemeteries. But where did these tales actually start? Turns out, the real history behind Southern folklore is wilder, stranger, and a whole lot darker than the stories themselves. With each episode, Liam uncovers the true tales hiding underneath the myths of the Gothic South.

Subscribe now and never miss a tale. And whatever you do tonight, be sure to lower the lights, lock the doors, and pull up a rocking chair. . . things are about to get interesting.