Henry Tolbert was sitting at a fire pit behind a rental house, grilling hot dogs for his wife and four daughters because the insurance money for their flooded home was running out, when he finally said out loud what he had been avoiding for months: this isn't fine.

A few years earlier, Henry had been leading a small church that grew from 40 people to nearly 200, and had been named bishop over 65 churches. Then, without warning, discord broke out with the leader who had brought him in, and he was forced to resign from everything at once. In that same season, an unidentified animal chewed through the water lines in the walls of his home, flooding the first floor and displacing his family for six weeks. He had no job, no income, and what he calls a broken sense of purpose.

On this episode of FINE is a 4-Letter Word, Henry tells Lori Saitz the full arc: a high school football career derailed by one injury after another, a scholarship earned in just five games, an NFL tryout built on the wrong game tape, a Bible study intervention that redirected him into ministry, and the fire pit moment that gave him permission to stop building other people's dreams and finally build his own.

What You'll Take Away

• Why a childhood dream pursued through repeated injury taught Henry more than an NFL career would have
• How losing his ministry role and his home in the same season forced an honest reckoning he had been avoiding for years
• Why judging his life by lead goals, the inputs he controls, instead of lag goals, the outcomes he doesn't, changed how he shows up every day
• What shifted when Henry stopped chasing clients and started inviting people instead
• How admitting he wasn't fine gave him permission to finally build something of his own

Guest Bio

Henry Tolbert spent years answering “How are you?” with “I'm fine” while quietly running on fumes, leading a church, building a business, and pretending he had it all together. Spoiler: he didn't. Now he's the Founder of Simple Systems Consulting, author of The Comeback Plan, and a recovering “I'm fine” addict who helps pastors and entrepreneurs stop white-knuckling their way through leadership and start building systems that actually let them breathe. He's also an Associate Pastor, podcast co-host, husband, dad of four, and a man who once grilled hot dogs over a fire pit in his backyard because life had completely fallen apart, and decided that was the last time he'd pretend everything was fine when it wasn't.

Chapters & Key Timestamps

00:00Opening and introductions — the Henry connection and generational names

01:33The values that shaped him: faith and football in Birmingham, Alabama

05:07A high school career derailed by injury after injury

07:07Five games, one scholarship, and a record-setting career at Grambling State

07:47What NFL scouts never saw: the tape from his best season

08:47His grandmother's plea to walk away — and why he couldn't

11:07The Bible study intervention that redirected him toward ministry

13:47“There's a light around you” — the moment that sealed it

14:47Becoming a bishop over 65 churches, then losing it overnight

15:47The critters, the flooded house, and six weeks displaced with four daughters

17:47The fire pit moment: admitting he wasn't fine

21:07Why people of faith are so good at sweeping things under the rug

25:47Lead goals vs. lag goals: judging life by inputs, not outcomes

27:47The coaching advice that changed everything: invite, don't chase

29:47Why the people who found him became his best clients

31:47Building an audience by just showing up, even when only his wife was watching

34:07In the Air Tonight by Phil Collins: Henry's walk-up song

35:07Where to find Henry: getchurchsystems.com and mybusinesssystems.com

Resources Mentioned

• Book: The Comeback Plan by Henry Tolbert
• Free Resource: Get Church Systems — getchurchsystems.com (for ministry and church leaders)
• Free Resource: My Business Systems — mybusinesssystems.com (for business owners and entrepreneurs)
• Resource: The Mandate Method — themandatemethod.com
• Song: In the Air Tonight by Phil Collins — open.spotify.com/track/7Dbg5O9nNWu6SWxDjJ9qoq

Connect With Henry Tolbert

Company: Simple Systems Consulting

Website: getchurchsystems.com

Website: mybusinesssystems.com

Website: themandatemethod.com

Book: The Comeback Plan

LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/henry-tolbert-005a3943

Facebook: facebook.com/htolbert

Instagram: instagram.com/henry_tolbert

Continue With Lori

Website: zenrabbit.com

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lorisaitz/

Email: Lori@ZenRabbit.com

Invitation From Lori

This episode is sponsored by Zen Rabbit. Trust is the foundation of all great workplaces, and in today's hybrid, fast-moving work culture, it's built through consistent, clear, human communication.

Quarterly town halls, Slack messages, or team-building events are rarely enough to create the connection employees need. That's why forward-thinking companies are hiring Lori to create internal and private podcasts that bring leaders and employees together through authentic stories and real conversations.

Think of it as the old-school company newsletter reinvented for the modern workplace.

If your company wants to strengthen communication, connection, community, and culture, connect with Lori at Lori@ZenRabbit.com or on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lorisaitz/

Related Conversation

Episode 237: Scott Doggett — a leader who lost his role suddenly and rebuilt around a clearer sense of who he actually was.

About FINE is a 4-Letter Word

FINE is a 4-Letter Word is the show for leaders who are tired of pretending everything is fine. We explore what it takes to lead with empathy, vulnerability, gratitude, and courage, especially during the seasons when life and leadership feel anything but fine. Listen for honest conversations about how human connection influences innovation, retention, leadership, and real impact. New episodes every week.

Follow FINE is a 4-Letter Word

Follow or subscribe so you never miss an episode. If this conversation gave you something useful to think about, leave a review. Reviews help more people discover the show and join the conversation.